What is the difference between astonishing x men and uncanny x men

Marvel, never one to miss a chance to capitalize on outside success, decided to do away with the traditional X-Men costumes and go with a look more akin to the movies. While Morrison made it make sense in the context of the comic, a lot of fans weren't happy at all about the X-Men losing their traditional looks. After Morrison's departure, costumes came back.

Marvel's first movie, Iron Man, didn't premiere until but these sorts of things take time to coalesce and Marvel had been planning to get into the movie business for years before that. Their biggest properties, the X-Men and Spider-Man, had been farmed out to stave off bankruptcy in the '90s, so they planned on using what they had.

That meant pushing the Avengers. By drastically reducing the number of mutants and pushing them into their own corner of the Marvel Universe, they could keep them out of the spotlight as much as possible and build up the characters whose movies they would be in charge of. The Fox movies all pretty much had the same villain for a long time and that was either Magneto or racist humans. While this made sense in a lot of ways, it also had a weird effect on the comics as for the first half of the s, classic X-Men villains beyond Magneto disappeared.

For Morrison's New X-Men it made sense but for the other books, it was kind of mystifying. Magneto would make an appearance, of course, and there were more racist humans than one could shake a stick at. While the stories were often good, losing villains like Mister Sinister, Apocalypse, and so many others for so long was a blow to the franchise.

This one was more akin to New Mutants or Generation X, highlighting a new generation of mutants. After House Of M, Marvel needed to drastically cut down on mutants, so they killed a lot of these young mutants. At the time, it felt gratuitous and for shock value. Looking back and seeing how Marvel would treat mutants in the future, and taking into account leaks from inside the company, it was done to spite Fox, cutting down on characters they could use in the movies and limiting the crossover appeal of the X-Men.

Morrison's New X-Men was truly something new, taking the trappings of the old and reforging them into revolution. Whedon's and Cassaday's Astonishing X-Men had its strengths but after Morrison's more dynamic take, it felt like a step into the past.

X-Men Gold Vol. Weapons of Mutant Destruction. Wolverine: Old Man Logan Vol. Generation X Vol. Iceman Vol. X-Men Blue Vol. Deadpool Vs. Old Man Logan. Cable Vol. X-Men Red Vol. Weapon H Vol. He's a long-time comic book fan, and can be seen most evenings in Batman pajama pants. Contact Dave comicbookherald on Twitter or via email at dave comicbookherald.

Along with the new mutants you provide the uncanny x-men that where released at the same time. Is it recommended to read both titles together or separate?

Hey the order of comics between Messiah Complex and Messiah War is a little confusing. So I think you should probably put X-Force 1- 13 after Cable 1- 10 so it flows better into Messiah War and include the issue by issue order for X-Men: Original Sin somewhere in there too. Lots of pretty significant things happen there. I actually started reading the modern X-Men at Messiah Complex outstanding story and found I had to go back a little to understand some things.

This site is fantastic! I just got a MU subscription this year and have decided to start reading the X-books from the Claremont-era, all the way up to present day-large task, I know. My biggest question is this: the last Uncanny book you mention in you Claremont reading guide is But you start this guide with Uncanny Have I missed another guide for that time period in those issues? I knew the X-Men titles could get confusing, but never knew there were this many titles!

Hello there! First I want to thank you for your work on this. My question is, do you recommend Avengers Xmen Axis? Honestly, Axis is one of my least favorite Marvel events. Not into TPB or single issues. I have literally gone from Muir Island Saga to All New all different Uncanny X-men by trade this year and your website was the torch in the darkness that is x-men continuity lol….

Thank you! A question: No District X after the first six-issue storyline? I know Mr. I have several pages bookmarked and have Excel spreadsheets based on this data to help me keep track of the TPBs I own and need. My question is do you have an essential list of X-Men comics of trades to read post Marvel Now? I liked all of the All-New X-men through Utopians. Apologies if this is too new and not enough data yet to post. Thanks again for the tremendously useful site.

Hey thanks! Now with MU i have started to read some again, like spider-man ultimate stopped at , and secret wars I big fan now and when i was young. Now i have started with the new x-men and planing what next, and with that i have some questions. I was thinking of some wolverin origin, emma frost, weapon x in that order with some Amazing Spider-Man on the side. So my question is, should I ignore the new x-men and go with my.

But I wanted to start from the beginning. I decided to start with the Uncanny X-men It starts out relatively easy understand, but then it starts referencing things that have happened and points me to another issue to understand what is going on. So i go the the suggested issue and then that issue suggests another issue to get the scoop. Where the heck do I even start??? But I want to know what the heck is going on. Is that of any particular significance?

Is it suggesting that the indented ones are read simultaneously? Or read optionally? Hi, first of all, just wanted to say great job on all your guides. What about 35? Where would they fit in?

Hi Dave, I just wanted to say that I enjoy your lists and have been using them for a while. For instance, the Claremont Excalibur run.

Do you plan to flesh out the Modern X-Men Reading Order with all of the x-men books or is this list just the ones you feel are important? I really want a list that breaks down everything X-Men related the way you do your reading orders. Is there something like that? Want to make sure I have the next order from there. Thanks, Phillip. I started reading Kingbreaker in preparation for War of Kings and was confused by the state of the Cosmic X-Men when I started reading. Now… Where do we go from here?

Hi Dave, thanks for an awesome effort. Why is there no mention of Xtreme X-Men in this list? Still better than Chuck Austen though. Anyway, is it missing from the Chronology because it kind of exists off in its own little corner of the world? Thank you so much for your amazing guides! It took some years to muster the courage, but it has been very rewarding. Your guides have been essential to me. So now for my quick question.

After reading this guide I will start off with New X-men. However, you also note the Uncanny X-men issues that are running alongside them. Would it be possible to start at UXM and get what is going on in that series? Are the two series closely related any any way?

Just trying to figure out if I should read both alongside each other, or just focus on the New issues. Hi, first I want to say this is amazing just like all of the lists on here, and keep up the good work.

Now, getting down to business. Im in highschool so I dont have alot of time to read comics, due to homework and various tv shows im watching. So, what titles do you feel are the most essential? It would be great to get an idea of what to read, so I dont waste time reading stories that dont really matter.

For X men, definitely concentrate on grant Morrisons x men and then joss whedons astonishing x men. Those are great and essential! I have a question about this reading list. Are these left off of this list because they are not recommended reading? Is there any value in trying to read some of these storylines as well? Do you recommend Exiles? I understand it is not very continuity heavy, is that right? All your guides are great, thanks for taking the time! Issue 70 is a House of M tie-in, so at that point you might want to loop back in with the state of the Marvel U.

Is all the links listed here for buying the TPBs or whatever, do they corner all the issues you list or is there a lot of single hunting? I use to be a big X-Men fan and had tons.

But stopped long ago and missed so much. Trying to find the best way and cheapest to get caught up. Much of this is covered in TPBs, but not all. Claremont X-Men era! First off thanks for amazing work. Are you supposed to read the 7 Astonishing issues before the nine Uncanny issues, and then the 4 issue miniseries?

Or are you supposed to read them in some sort of alternating fashion. This is, of course, just one example of many such in your list and I just wanted to gain some more clarity on that. Good question. Generally speaking, I would say you can read the complete story arc so all 7 issues of astonishing at once, and then move on to the next series. Can you explain or point me in the direction where you have already explained How your specific reading orders i.

Are these a part of the guide, just pulled out and separated for fans of the individual series that might not want to read all of the other titles? Anyway your site continues to impress me, keep up the most appreciated work.

No problem, put together some thoughts on your question here. Your email address will not be published. DC Where to Start? Comments this guide is incredible, thank you for putting it together! Sure, you could. What about All-new All-different? This list has some titles indented from the rest. Loving the guide so far. Thanks for what must have been a monumental effort. Thanks in advance. I love this site! I have pretty much every other page bookmarked!

The team faced off against Cassandra Nova, giving Jean Grey a chance to display her impressive Omega-Level mutant powers. She defeated Nova by projecting a false construct, not unlike Luke Skywalker did in the climactic scene of The Last Jedi.

One of the best X-Men rosters wasn't officially called the X-Men. Excalibur was essentially the British branch of the team, formed in the tragic aftermath of the apparent death of the main X-Men team. The zany tone of the book, especially in the early issues written by Chris Claremont and drawn by Alan Davis, distinguished it from the often melancholic tone of the X-Men during the late '80s.

The team was also early explorers of the multiverse, something the MCU seems poised to investigate itself in the near future. Kitty Pryde has been at the heart of many X-Men rosters over the years. One of the best is her current team, the Marauders. With Kitty now closely aligned with the club as it's Red Queen, she, along with the White Queen, Storm, Bishop, Iceman, and Pyro all play a major role in the unfolding drama in the current X-Men comics.

The original team of X-Men remains one of the most iconic in all of Marvel Comics. The original five X-Men, including Cyclops, Jean Grey, Beast, Iceman, and Angel, remain the foundation for the sprawling team and its ancillaries today.

All of the original members have grown and evolved in fascinating ways in the last sixty years, but their youthful optimism and innocence remain compelling and could potentially serve as the method for how the MCU chooses to introduce mutants into the franchise. The New Mutants movie may not have been worth the delay for the movie , but the comic book team the movie was based on is among the best.

The concept behind the New Mutants was a class of new trainees to graduate into the X-Men.